Features
Contact
AOL IM

2003 Milk Plus Droogies

Best Picture
Kill Bill Vol. I

Best Director
Quentin Tarantino, Kill Bill Vol. I

Best Actor (tie)
Johnny Depp, Pirates of the Caribbean

Best Actor (tie)
Bill Murray, Lost in Translation

Best Actress
Uma Thurman, Kill Bill Vol. I

Best Supporting Actor
David Hyde Pierce, Down With Love

Best Supporting Actress
Miranda Richardson, Spider

Best Screenplay
Sofia Coppola, Lost in Translation

Best Foreign Film
Irreversible

Best Cinematography
Harris Savides, Gerry

Members' Marquees

Critical Contacts

Lobby Reading

The Video Store

Reel Resources

The Blog Bijou

-213
-Admit One
-Artistic Delusions
-Belligerent Bunny's Bad Movie Shrine
-Beware of Blog
-The Brain Drain
Biancolo Notes
-The Big Ticket
-Bitter Cinema
-Black & White World
-Bull Durham's Hot Corner
-Brewed Fresh Daily
-Camille's Film Journal
-Chiragdshah
-The Chutry Experiment
-Cineblog
-Cineblog (II)
-Cine Club
-Cinecultist
-Cinegraphic.Net: The Avante-Garde Film and Video Blog
-Cinema 24
-CinemaMinima
-Cinema News
-Il Cinema Secondo (Italian)
-Cineaste (Russian)
-Cinematix
-Cinema Toast
-Cinetrix
-Columbina
-Concentrated Nonsense
-Confessions of an Indie Filmmaker
-Cult Movies I Dare You to Watch
-Cutting to the Chase
Cybersam
-Cynthia Rockwell's Waiting Room
-The Daily Despair
-The Daily Digest
-Day for Night
-Delta Sierra Arts
-Dinky's Docket
-Distorting the Medium
-Donald Melanson On Movies
-Electric Movies
-Fade In: Blog
-Feeling Listless
-Filmfilter (German)
-Filmgurlland
-FilmingtonBlog
-Filmtagebuch (German)
-Film Talk
-Five Easy Pieces
-Fluxblog
-Frank Booth
-Fringe
-A Girl and A Gun
-Glazed Donuts
-Greg.org
-GreenCine Daily
-Harlequin Knights
-Harrylimetheme
-He Loved Him Some Movies
-The Hobo Reviews
-Hot Buttered Death
-Iggy's Movie Review Weblog
-Iguano Film Blog
-In Development
-Indigoblog
-Ionarts
-Ishbadiddle
-Japanese Films' Journal
-Joe Sixpack's Film Blog
-Joe's Weblog & Film Project News
-Junk for Code
-Kumari's Movie Blog
-Lights Out Films
-Like Anna Karina's Sweater (Filmbrain)
-Listen Missy
-Loebrich.org
-Magnolia Girl
-Marley's Ghost
-Media Yenta
-Michael I. Trent
-Moovees.com
-Moov Goog
-Motime Like the Present
-MovieBlog
-Movie Boy
-Movie Criticism For the Retarded
-A Movie Diary
-The Movie Generation
-Moviehead
-The Movie Marketing Blog
-Movie Retard
-The Movie Review
-MovieTawk
-Moving Pictures
-Nando's Blog
-Netflix Fan
-Odeon
-Onethumbsideways
-Or Kill Me
-Out of Ambit
-Out of Focus
-Paolo - Cinema's Radio Weblog (Italian)
-Pigs and Battleships
-Plot Kicks In
-Pop Culture Junkies
-Popthoughts
-The Projector
-Qwipster's Movie Reviews
-Rashomon
-Rawbrick.Net
-Reel Reviews (Podcast)
-Reviews, Reviews, Reviews
-Salocin.com
-SciFiDaily
-The Screening Room
-Screen Watcher
-Shikaku
-Short and Sweet
-The Silver Screen
-Solipsist
-Stinky Cinema
-Sunset Blvd
-Tagline: A Movie Weblog
Talking Pictures
Tea for One
-Tofuhut
-Tom Vick's Asian Cinema Blog
-Trailer Park
-Truly Bad Films
Waste of Tape
-Wayne's Movie Blog
Whippin Picadilly
Wittgenstein's Bunnies
-Yay! Movies!
McBain Recommends
-Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
-Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
-Kill Bill vol 2
Shroom Recommends
-Top 20 List
-Brothers
-Head On
-Moolade
Joker Recommends
-Top 20 List
-House of Flying Daggers
-The Aviator
-Bad Education
Yun-Fat Recommends
-Eight Diagram Pole Fighter
-Los Muertos
-Tropical Malady
Allyn Recommends
-Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
-Songs from the Second Floor
Phyrephox Recommends
-Top 20 List
-Design for Living (Lubitsch, 1933)
-War of the Worlds
-Howl's Moving Castle
Melisb Recommends
-Top 20 List
-The Return
-Spirited Away
-Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter...And Spring
Wardpet Recommends
-Finding Nemo
-Man on the Train
-28 Days Later
Lorne Recommends
-21 Grams
-Cold Mountain
-Lost in Translation
Merlot Recommends
-Top 20 List
-The Man on the Train
-Safe Conduct
-The Statement
Whitney Recommends
-Femme Fatale
-Gangs of New York
-Grand Illusion
Sydhe Recommends
-In America
-Looney Tunes: Back In Action
-Whale Rider
Copywright Recommends
Top 20 List
-Flowers of Shanghai
-Road to Perdition
-Topsy-Turvy
Stennie Recommends
Top 20 List
-A Matter of Life and Death
-Ossessione
-Sideways
Rodney Recommends
Top 20 List
-Chicago
-The Pianist
-Talk to Her
Jeff Recommends
-Dial M for Murder
-The Game
-Star Wars Saga
Lady Wakasa Recommends
-Dracula: Page from a Virgin's Diary
-Dr. Mabuse, Der Spieler
-The Last Laugh
Steve Recommends
-Top 20 List
-Princess Raccoon
-Princess Raccoon
-Princess Raccoon
Jenny Recommends
-Mean Girls
-Super Size Me
-The Warriors
Jason Recommends
Top 20 List
-Old Boy
-Million Dollar Baby
-Head On
Lons Recommends
-Before Sunset
-The Incredibles
-Sideways

Powered by Blogger Pro™



links open windows

(c)2002 Design by Blogscapes.com



The Blog:
Thursday, April 18, 2002
 
Frailty Spoilers

I tried to write this as comments under Shroom's post, but it was too long. So here it is as a post/review:

That I think the film pretty much sucks is beside the point -- the questions I have are practical, factual, and objective questions. (We could argue the aesthetic worth of it all day, and apparently disagree). First of all, I think it's clear that Adam and Dad could really see evil visions, that they really were doing God's work, and that the people they killed were all killers themselves. (There's no other explanation for Doyle asking Adam how he knew Doyle killed his mother: the only way Adam'd know is by getting his name from God on that list, then touching Doyle to confirm it). Shroom's explanation that maybe Adam is just a keen detective is thrown out the window when you consider that Paxton would have had to have been an equally good detective (to sniff out the pedophiles and what not), and that's clearly not what's going on.

I agree that the script is neither pro- nor anti-religion, because its waters are muddied by a hyopcrisy: on the pro side, God does exist and is correct when identifying murderers; on the negative side God's will turns men into killers, too, (and even the Old Testament has God saying murder is wrong) and they sometimes have to kill good people (like the Sheriff).

So now that I've said what I think the facts are (i.e., Adam and Dad really did have visions and were destroying "demons"), I do think there are holes here. One is, Adam comes to Doyle at the beginning and says "my brother is the killer." Dolye says, "how do you know?" And Adam tells the story up to the point that Paxton kills the first nurse lady. Then Adam says "see now why I think my brother's the killer?" And Doyle seems to buy this. Wouldn't Doyle say, "uh, actually, dude, it sounds like your Dad's the killer, not your brother."? Why does he buy the brother story at this point? Next, the film doesn't really make it clear that there has been a second series of murders -- for a while I was thinking that the God's Hand Killer that Adam is confessing about is his Dad, the one who killed the nurse and the pedophile, etc. But it's not. Fenton has gone on a killing spree, apparently, and that's the guy that Doyle is hunting. If this is the case, why are they called God's Hand murders? God's Hand murders would be done by Dad or Adam -- people to whom Angels visited. If Fenton was just a normal demon killing normal people, it wouldn't be a "God's Hand" killer. He wouldn't plant letters talking about "there will be no more bodies; I'm hiding them, etc." It would be Adam and Dad who were taking lives through God's Hand. Another small problem is that Paxton says the Angel told him he would deliver 3 weapons ("Magic weapons, dad?"). But he only delivers two: the lead pipe and the Otis axe (and who the fuck is Otis? and why doesn't that come into play at all?). I guess Angels can't count to three, or else were keeping a grenade or something for themselves.

Anyway, to answer the question "why didn't Paxton see that Fenton was evil when he touched him" is clear to me: because Fenton hadn't killed anyone yet, so there was nothing to see. The Angel told Dad Fenton was a demon, and the Angel was right. There was just no evil to see yet. Dad just didn't want to believe (there's that word again -- it's all about faith) that Fenton was evil, so he didn't have faith enough to kill him or see evil.

I don't know why I've just spent 20 minutes typing this out. This review should have gone into the aesthetic reasons why I thought the film sucked -- besides plot holes, there's the shoddy cinematography (by the guy who did Jaws, no less), the poor acting on the part of the kids (sorry, but Osment raised the bar), the dull, bland dialogue (should have been leavened with a sense of humor, but there's only one or two [intentional] laughs in it), and the utter predictability of the suspense (I saw Fenton axing Dad from a mile away, and I saw Doyle's complicity in "something" from the opening shot when he evily gets out of the car and goes into the station asking if McC asked for him by name. You just know something's up). Overall, I don't care that the film confirms the existence of God and demons and supports serial killings and that I'm an atheist and oppose serial killings. What I do care about is that it's a poorly written and cheaply structured shaggy dog story that needed to conceal Adam's lie (saying his name was Fenton) for no good reason in order to give us the "Usual Suspects" twist it needed to put butts in seats. Yawn.